If you’ve had the privilege of visiting the beautiful island of Puerto Rico, I really hope you made time to taste Piña Coladas at at least one watering hole. A frozen rum drink made with creamy coconut and tropical pineapple, Piña Coladas have been Puerto Rico’s national drink since the late seventies.
The Drama Behind Piña Coladas
The drama that surrounds the origin of the Piña Colada is hilarious. Well, I mean, it’s not “drama” drama. It’s more like one dude flexin’ on another one. According to legend, whomever made piña coladas first, did so as a way to appease tourists and the drink became a success. Isn’t it funny how all recipes began with a harried chef or bartender who needed to make some royal or obnoxious tourist happy?
Supposedly, the first person to create the piña colada was a bartender at the posh Caribe Hilton in San Juan. According to him, he created it in the late 50s. But, then, in the early sixties, a restaurant in Old San Juan, Barrachina, claimed their bartender created the cocktail. So, they said, “Well, how about we plaster this MARBLE PLAQUE on the outside of our place claiming we invented the drink?!?” And, guess what? That’s exactly what they did!! You can’t tell me that’s not the ultimate flex. How does the Caribe Hilton respond to a freakin’ memorial that claims they didn’t create jack? They don’t, that’s how. Well, ever since, there’s been a debate about who invented what and when.
Not that any of that even matters because everybody and their mother makes amazing piña coladas in Puerto Rico. If you drive down the highway from San Juan to Loíza, alone, you can choose from tons of kiosks on the side of the road that are blending these cocktails. And, you know what? They’re all amazing. Even if you are a tourist, you don’t need to jostle with the other travelers to experience “authentic” piña coladas. Go to the quiet towns and have a seat at any bar and you’ll be amazed.
What isn’t debatable is what goes into piña coladas. Pineapple, usually in the form of juice (and sometimes fresh fruit) is a must. Coconut- by way of cream of coconut- and rum are also essential. The most commonly used rums are white or gold. Ice, to make it slushy, and your choice of garnishes to make it purty.
What you’ll need to make these Piña Coladas
For starters, you will need a can of cream of coconut. You’ll also need pineapple juice, white (or gold) rum, brown sugar (this is optional), pineapple chunks (also optional), and a few handfuls of ice. A garnish of whipped cream is common. I like to add a slice of fresh pineapple and a maraschino cherry to my cocktails as well.
¡Vamonos! (That’s Spanish for “let’s go”)
Fill the Blender
Begin by adding the cream of coconut to your high speed blender. I avoid putting ice in the blender first because my drink ends up with more ice chunks when I do. In this recipe, I use a whole can of cream of coconut. It’s mainly because I have no use for the half a can of the stuff that will be leftover. I mean, no other use except to make more piña coladas. So, why not just make a whole pitcherful of the stuff? I also use a whole can because I like an even balance of piña to coco flavor.
What’s the Difference Between Cream of Coconut and Everything Else?
Cream of coconut is not the same thing as coconut cream or coconut milk. If coconut cream and coconut milk are sisters, cream of coconut is their cousin who the family only sees at weddings and funerals. They all take meds to make their family feel more normal. That means, all of these canned coconut products have added stabilizers (like guar gum) to make them shelf-stable. Let’s briefly discuss what makes them different.
Coconut cream and milk are the unsweetened products of coconut meat and water that’s been blended together to form a coconutty liquid. Much like cow’s milk, their names “cream” and “milk” are indicators of how rich (or fatty) they are. Cream is much richer than milk is, as it has a higher percentage of coconut fat to water in its makeup. Coconut milk has less coconut fat so it’s not as rich. Both of these coconut products are used in cooking, baking, and cocktail-making. For the sweeter recipes, you may need add sugar to sweeten them up a bit. When baking with coconut cream, be mindful that its higher percentage of fat may alter your recipe’s outcome.
As for our recipe’s star, cream of coconut, she’s a whole different beast. Instead of blending just coconut meat and water together, cream of coconut has a good amount of sugar that’s also added to it. As a result of the higher sugar content, it’s not an ingredient you’d use in savory recipes. Therefore, cream of coconut is used, almost exclusively, in dessert and cocktail recipes.
Coconut Water? LOL!
Yes, there’s also coconut water. Coconut water is the drunk uncle who no one wants at the party. I avoid bottled coconut water like the plague because it tastes artificial. I mean, I have sipped it straight from the coconut, so there’s that. Because I think it’s blasphemous, I won’t go into further detail on it. I want no parts of it.
Back to the DRANK…
Okay! Now that we’ve beaten the coconut horse to death, let’s reward ourselves with our piña coladas.
Add the pineapple juice to the blender. I also like to add pineapple chunks because it makes my drink more like a smoothie. The addition of fresh pineapple is totally optional, though. Fresh pineapple juice is best, but canned is totally acceptable. It is what they use in bars, after all.
Now’s a good time to add the ice and, my secret, a hint of brown sugar. While, again, totally optional, I love the depth of flavor the brown sugar adds to the drink.
Piña Coladas NEED Good Rum
Please don’t add gut-rot rum to your piña coladas. Yes, it’s a mixed drink, so you don’t need to bust out a $100 special edition bottle. But, you should at least use mid-shelf liquor. Bacardí is probably the rum most associated with piña coladas, but it’s not Puerto Rican rum. It’s Cuban. Yes, it can still be used, as you can see from my image, but if you want to keep this as Puerto Rican as possible, use a rum from Puerto Rico like Don Q or Palo Viejo.
Whether to use white or gold (or amber) rum is simply a matter of taste. If you’re into a clean, crisp cocktail, use the white. Do you have an affinity for deeper, sweeter flavors? Go with the gold. The difference between the two is a matter of how, and how long, one has been aged. White rum is not aged, nor is it stored in special casks. Gold rum is aged for a specified period of time, usually in wooden casks. That’s what gives it its telltale color and flavor.
I had white Bacardí on the shelf, so that’s what’s going into my blender.
Blend the mixture
Place the lid on your blender and blend the mixture for 30 seconds to 1 minute, or until smooth.
Pour and Garnish your Piña Coladas
That’s it! I love these easy-to-make recipes, don’t you?
Pour your smooth piña colada mixture into cocktail glasses.
Serve the drinks as is, or garnish the piña coladas with sweetened whipped cream, a maraschino cherry, and a slice of fresh pineapple. As you can see, I went with all of the above. Don’t fuss about with piping that whipped cream, either. Just drop a spoonful on top and keep it moving.
Settling is Normal
If you’ve never had a homemade piña colada, you may be surprised that the drink will settle as it sits. The reason why it doesn’t settle in bars is because most bars use slushy machines to make theirs. Settling in your piña coladas is totally normal as the fat from the cream of coconut wants to rise above the lighter juice and rum. Don’t stress over it, just use your straw to swirl it together again.
I mean, after a few sips, you won’t even give a damn.
Make it Virgin
If you have little munchkins who will stare you down until they get their own piña coladas- like I do- go ahead and whip them up a batch of their own virgin versions. Simply omit the rum and add a little bit of water to the mix instead. Kids need a little love, but they don’t need a little rum, so leave it out.
I hope you like my version of the national drink of Puerto Rico. Please, let me know what you think of these piña coladas and be sure to pin and share this recipe with your world.
Piña Coladas (Pineapple-Coconut Cocktails with Rum)at Sense & Edibility
- High-speed blender
- 15 ounce can cream of coconut
- 2 cups pineapple juice
- 1 cup fresh pineapple chunks optional
- 1 tablespoon light brown sugar optional
- 4 cups ice
- 6-8 ounces white or gold rum
- 1 cup sweetened whipped cream
- 4 sliced pineapple wedges
- 4 maraschino cherries
- In a blender, layer the ingredients in the following order: cream of coconut, pineapple juice, pineapple chunks (if using), sugar, ice, rum.
- Blend the mixture together until smooth, about 30 seconds to 1 minute.
- Pour the piña colada mixture into cocktail glasses and top with sweetened whipped cream.
- Garnish your piña coladas with a maraschino cherry and pineapple slice.
Omit the rum and replace it with 1/2-1 cup of cold water. Blend as instructed. For a lighter coconut flavor:
Use 7 1/2 ounces of cream of coconut instead of the full can.
If you like these Piña Coladas,
you’ll love my other libations:
Tamarind Añejo Margarita
I love pina coladas especially when it is a delicious combination like this one! thank you for sharing this recipe, I cant wait to make these during the summer holidays!
This recipe makes the best pina coladas. They come out sweet, rich, and creamy, It is the perfect cocktail treat to have at the end of a hot summer day.
I couldn’t agree more, Katie.
I adore pina coladas and knew I had to try your recipe. This is the best pina colada I have ever made. So easy and so good!
Thank you for your feedback, Debbie!
I made a batch of these delicious drinks for our 4th of July celebration. They were a hit! I loved that I could easy get all the ingredients for such a fun and tropical drink.
So happy to hear that, Amy!
You cannot beat a classic homemade pina colada. I love how you break down the best ingredients to use and why too.
Thank you, Sharon!
Lol, love the drama behind the colada part – interesting stuff!! And the quality rum suggestion makes all the difference. Thanks!
You’re welcome, Jessica!